A History of the Warfare of Science with Theology in Christendom, Volume One


Read by John Greenman

(5 stars; 3 reviews)

The 21st Century, so far, has seen a dramatic and widespread questioning of "Science", much of it from "Evangelicals". But this attack on science is nothing new! Author White, in the late 1800's put it this way: from his introduction: "In all modern history, interference with science in the supposed interest of religion, no matter how conscientious such interference may have been, has resulted invariably, in the direst evils both to religion and to science; on the other hand, all untrammeled scientific investigation, no matter how dangerous to religion some of its stages may have seemed for the time to be, has invariably resulted in the highest good, both of religion and of science."

In these volumes, White chronicles the gradual emancipation of science from theology in various fields.

But White's work has been condemned by modern researchers! Historian of science and agnostic Ronald Numbers has stated, in a collection dealing with inaccuracies made by White and others, "Historians of science have known for years that White's ... accounts are more propaganda than history."

Biographer Albert Bigelow Paine mentioned that this book was one of Mark Twain's favorite books, near the end of his life. Barbara Schmidt, in her TwainQuotes.com says, "Mark Twain referred to Dickson's book saying, 'When you read it you see how those old theologians never reasoned at all'" Twain's personal copy of White's two volumes are heavily marked with his marginalia. - Summary by John Greenman & Wikipedia

Note: White's voluminous reference notes and commentary have been edited out for this recording. Here, they are referred to as "note one...note two...etc." and can be found in the original transcription at the Gutenberg Project link: https://www.gutenberg.org/ebooks/505 (16 hr 45 min)

Chapters

Introduction 20:53 Read by John Greenman
Chap. 1 - From Creation to Evolution. Section 1 - The Visible Universe 56:31 Read by John Greenman
Chap. 1 - Section 2 - Theological Teachings regarding the Animals and Man 1:04:46 Read by John Greenman
Chap. 1 - Section 3 - Theological and Scientific Theories of an Evolution in An… 52:01 Read by John Greenman
Chap. 1 - Section 4 - The Final Effort of Theology 42:59 Read by John Greenman
Chap. 2 - Geography - Section 1 - The Form of the Earth 21:22 Read by John Greenman
Chap. 2 - Section 2 - The Delineation of the Earth 7:27 Read by John Greenman
Chap. 2 - Section 3 - The Inhabitants of the Earth 17:52 Read by John Greenman
Chap. 2 - Section 4 - The Size of the Earth 4:47 Read by John Greenman
Chap. 2 - Section 5 - The Character of the Earth's Surface 3:25 Read by John Greenman
Chap. 3 - Astronomy - Section 1 - The Old Sacred Theory of the Universe 14:11 Read by John Greenman
Chap. 3 - Section 2 - The Heliocentric Theory 22:59 Read by John Greenman
Chap. 3 - Section 3 - The War Upon Galileo 23:08 Read by John Greenman
Chap. 3 - Section 4 - Victory of the Church over Galileo 29:42 Read by John Greenman
Chap. 3 - Section 5 - Results of the Victory over Galileo 13:00 Read by John Greenman
Chap. 3 - Section 6 - The Retreat of the Church after its Victory over Galileo 28:10 Read by John Greenman
Chap. 4 - From "Signs and Wonders" to Law in the Heavens - Section 1 - The Theo… 27:12 Read by John Greenman
Chap. 4 - Section 2 - Theological Efforts to Crush the Scientific View 36:36 Read by John Greenman
Chap. 4 - Section 3 - The Invasion of Scepticism 13:30 Read by John Greenman
Chap. 4 - Section 4 - Theological Efforts at Compromise - The Final Victory of … 16:34 Read by John Greenman
Chap. 5 - From Genesis to Geology - Section 1 - Growth of Theological Explanati… 13:43 Read by John Greenman
Chap. 5 - Section 2 - Efforts to Suppress the Scientific View 25:05 Read by John Greenman
Chap. 5 - Section 3 - The First Great Effort at Compromise, Based on the Flood … 34:45 Read by John Greenman
Chap. 5 - Section 4 - Final Efforts at Compromise - the Victory of Science Comp… 23:07 Read by John Greenman
Chap. 6 - The Antiquity of Man, Eqyptology, and Assyriology- Section 1 - The Sa… 20:02 Read by John Greenman
Chap. 6 - Section 2 - The New Chronology 20:44 Read by John Greenman
Chap. 7 - The Antiquity of Man and Prehistoric Archeology - Section 1 - The Thu… 13:39 Read by John Greenman
Chap. 7 - Section 2 - The Flint Weapons and Implements 27:47 Read by John Greenman
Chap. 8 - The "Fall of Man" and Anthropology 44:01 Read by John Greenman
Chap. 9 - The "Fall of Man" and Ethnology 16:05 Read by John Greenman
Chap. 10 - The "Fall of Man" and History 31:31 Read by John Greenman
Chap. 11 - From "The Prince of the Power of the Air" to Meteorology - Section 1… 31:57 Read by John Greenman
Chap. 11 - Section 2 - Diabolical Agency in Storms 32:43 Read by John Greenman
Chap. 11 - Section 3 - The Agency of Witches 30:30 Read by John Greenman
Chap. 11 - Section 4 - Franklin's Lightning Rod 23:14 Read by John Greenman
Chap. 12 - From Magic to Chemistry and Physics - Section 1 1:13:04 Read by John Greenman
Chap. 12 - From Magic to Chemistry and Physics - Section 2 26:58 Read by John Greenman

Reviews


(5 stars)

Arguably, the best intellectual history in LibriVox